Georgia’s frozen dessert scene just earned some serious street cred: four shops made it onto Yelp’s prestigious 2025 list of the Top 100 Ice Cream Shops in the country. This is not a casual ranking. It reflects analysis of thousands of reviews, health inspection data, and the total volume and quality of feedback as of mid April 2025. Whether it is vegan innovation in urban Atlanta or creamy custard delights in the suburbs, these shops each bring something uniquely delicious. This article dives into what makes them stand out, how they deliver their flavors, and what research backs their acclaim, offering everything a sweet tooth reader really needs to know.
1. Eighty7sweets Vegan Ice Cream (Atlanta)
Yelp Top-100 rank: #38
Eighty7sweets crafts oat and almond milk based ice creams in small daily batches, taking up to six hours for flavor depth. Known for seasonal creations, it proves vegan scoops can rival dairy, with Yelp data citing strong reviews and a clean April 2025 health score.
Where to find it: 56 Broad St NW, Atlanta, GA 30303.
2. Scoopjoy Ice Creamery (Suwanee)
Yelp Top-100 rank: #49
Scoopjoy prepares custard each morning using local dairy and seasonal ingredients. The eight to ten hour process develops flavors like butter pecan. High Yelp ratings and spotless inspections highlight why early visits secure the freshest churns and best customer experiences.
Where to find it: 2780 W Village Dr, Suite C, Suwanee, GA 30024.
3. Berens Frozen Custard (Grayson)
Yelp Top-100 rank: #87
Berens perfects custard using egg rich bases and slow churning over eight hours, yielding dense creamy scoops. Loyal community reviews and an April 2025 health pass secured its spot. Midday visits ensure the smoothest texture, with toppings adding a custom touch.
Where to find it : 420 Grayson Parkway, Grayson, GA 30017, with another location at 156 E Crogan St, Lawrenceville, GA.
4. The Ice Cream Stop (Richmond Hill)
Yelp Top-100 rank: #93
The Ice Cream Stop blends local and national brands with house made specialties. Flavors are prepped six hours ahead so mix ins fuse well. Yelp’s review data and April 2025 health score confirm quality. Bryan County public reporting (compiled by regional outlets pulling from Georgia DPH) shows a 96 score for The Ice Cream Stop on Feb 4, 2025. Afternoon trips offer the freshest featured items.
Where to find it: 13300 GA Hwy 144, Richmond Hill, GA 31324
Comments